The date on this is a bit confusing, as it was filmed at performance held in 2016, though the film itself was released in 2020.
I learned a lot from this film. First, Alexander Hamilton was Latino, and a master at rap battles. Also, that most of the founding fathers were black, and that racial diversity means making 3/4 of your cast black, without only one person who is half Asian, but no native Americans, Arabs or any other races. And that a white parents can have two black daughters, and one half Chinese daughter. And finally, that Thomas Jefferson was actually Prince. I had no idea that randomly dancing was so common in colonial times, as well. So the point being, this fantasy is clearly the product of it's times, with racial diversity triumphing over historical accuracy.
I had heard this was a great musical, and so I wanted to check it out for myself.
This film / musical is my worst fears of what musicals would be prior to my having ever seen a musical as a kid. It's people signing sporadically for no reason, as well as dancing. And the style of this film is that the everyone is constantly signing, so that there are about 50 songs in this musical, one after another, from the very beginning until the very end. I watched this film with subtitles turned on, and when people sing, it is often hard to make out the words, I would think the story would be lost if I had seen in live on stage.
Also, all of the songs are completely unremarkable. There is a lot of word repetition with a lot of the chorus repeating what the lead singer sings, and even some points where the lyrics are merely vocables (such as Da da da dat da dat da da da da ya da). None of the songs stand out as emotional high points, nor do they have a catchy tune.
All of the action takes place on a single, nondescript set. It doesn't appear to be a colonial setting, as the walls are at least two stories tall and brick.
While I realize that the creator of this musical is also the lead actor, and that is admirable in itself, I still prefer more of a story, with more depth than this musical goes into.
While the Founding Father Hamilton's life should really be better known, there are only 5 points that are relevant. In this musical, those points are brought out every 3rd song or so.
1) He was born in the Caribbean, and lost both his mother and father at a young age.
2) He was the first Treasury Secretary and he created the banking system for the US
3) He cheated on his wife (though it appears to that he was tricked, to a point)
4) His son died in a duel
5) He died in a duel.
One other point is that his wife created an orphanage
This musical completely omits Alexander Hamilton's 7 other children, making it seem like Philip, who died, was his only child.
These are my comments on the films that I have chosen to watch, and the reason I choose to watch them. I have not added any recaps of the films plots, as I hate how reviewers do so, ruining the film for you and just filling up space If you want to know the plots of these films, Wikipedia has done a better job than I could do.
Showing posts with label Musical. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Musical. Show all posts
Tuesday, January 26, 2021
Sunday, April 10, 2016
Fiddler on the Roof (1971)
I had been going through all the old musicals that I was aware of, and Fiddler on the Roof was one that I had never seen. I have heard the music many times, but never seen the film 'til now.
I have heard the songs "If I were a Rich Man" and "Matchmaker" repeatedly over the years. And even the song Tradition sounded familiar. Strangely, it didn't seem like there were that many other songs in the film, especially not that many that really stood out.
The film is rather long, but doesn't feel overly long, even though I feel as if the story could have been told in a much shorter time period.
The story is simple, but one that has been covered many times before in various cultural settings. One other kind of odd thing about the film is the daughters in the film are occasionally referred to as beautiful, but they don't seem to be particularly outstandingly good looking.
For most of the story, while we are aware they live in a Jewish settlement, most of what takes place and their costumes don't stand out as being very Jewish to me. Not that I didn't feel they were authentic, but it seems that when people mention people as being Jewish in the past, one often congers up images of orthodox Jews.
It's some what surpring how compliantly the Jews left their homes when commanded to. But I guess they had a choice between leaving on their own or being removed.
The concept of a fiddler on the roof and the meaning are never really explained, and a source of puzzlement.
I have heard the songs "If I were a Rich Man" and "Matchmaker" repeatedly over the years. And even the song Tradition sounded familiar. Strangely, it didn't seem like there were that many other songs in the film, especially not that many that really stood out.
The film is rather long, but doesn't feel overly long, even though I feel as if the story could have been told in a much shorter time period.
The story is simple, but one that has been covered many times before in various cultural settings. One other kind of odd thing about the film is the daughters in the film are occasionally referred to as beautiful, but they don't seem to be particularly outstandingly good looking.
For most of the story, while we are aware they live in a Jewish settlement, most of what takes place and their costumes don't stand out as being very Jewish to me. Not that I didn't feel they were authentic, but it seems that when people mention people as being Jewish in the past, one often congers up images of orthodox Jews.
It's some what surpring how compliantly the Jews left their homes when commanded to. But I guess they had a choice between leaving on their own or being removed.
The concept of a fiddler on the roof and the meaning are never really explained, and a source of puzzlement.
Tuesday, March 22, 2011
Flower Drum Song
Continuing on, as with the previous film, I had heard the title of this song, but never seen the film. In fact, after watching the film I had never even heard most of the songs, though I think I may have heard the song "The Other Generation" once or twice. The song, "Love, Look Away" is excellent and I am surprised it hasn't gotten more attention.
One odd thing about the film is that 3 of the four stars are Japanese (well two Japanese American and one from Japan) playing a Chinese character roll with the other actress being the half Chinese and half Scottish Nancy Kwan, who has immeasurable appeal in this film, and perhaps all her films.
I was very impressed to see the "typical" life of Chinese American's speaking without accents. And even more impressed for them to included a Chinese character who had just arrived, speaking with an accent. The film didn't give in to the preconception that all Asians (and Asian Americans) speak with an accent, nor did to attempt to completely erase that fact that some do. This seems like and extremely enlightened view for the time this film was made and it's surprising that even in current times some non Asians retain this faulty preconception.
The film is colorful and enjoyable, though some what lacking in memorable songs. Also, felt the Mei Li was not particularly interesting, nor did I see any motivation for the romance between the two main characters.
One odd thing about the film is that 3 of the four stars are Japanese (well two Japanese American and one from Japan) playing a Chinese character roll with the other actress being the half Chinese and half Scottish Nancy Kwan, who has immeasurable appeal in this film, and perhaps all her films.
I was very impressed to see the "typical" life of Chinese American's speaking without accents. And even more impressed for them to included a Chinese character who had just arrived, speaking with an accent. The film didn't give in to the preconception that all Asians (and Asian Americans) speak with an accent, nor did to attempt to completely erase that fact that some do. This seems like and extremely enlightened view for the time this film was made and it's surprising that even in current times some non Asians retain this faulty preconception.
The film is colorful and enjoyable, though some what lacking in memorable songs. Also, felt the Mei Li was not particularly interesting, nor did I see any motivation for the romance between the two main characters.
Music Man
I grew up with several records of 60's musicals, and have seen a number of those films. Still there were a few that I had heard of, but never really listened to the music nor ever seen the films.
It is for that reason I added a few of those films, who's names I have known so well to my list of films to watch.
Music Man was an enjoyable enough film, with a few memorable tunes, especially "76 Trombones" and "Ya Got Trouble". As I said, the film was enjoyable enough, but I didn't get a strong feeling for the characters (I guess that is typical for musicals) nor did I feel that there was a real love in any of the brewing romance.
It was really good to see Buddy Hacket, as I only recall seeing him in "The Love Bug" and as the voice of scuttle in The Little Mermaid. He has an interesting personality on film, but his bungling tenancies are completely absent in this film. Also it was good to see Shirley Jones, who I only recall from the Partridge Family and also Ron Howard in one of his earliest roles.
It is for that reason I added a few of those films, who's names I have known so well to my list of films to watch.
Music Man was an enjoyable enough film, with a few memorable tunes, especially "76 Trombones" and "Ya Got Trouble". As I said, the film was enjoyable enough, but I didn't get a strong feeling for the characters (I guess that is typical for musicals) nor did I feel that there was a real love in any of the brewing romance.
It was really good to see Buddy Hacket, as I only recall seeing him in "The Love Bug" and as the voice of scuttle in The Little Mermaid. He has an interesting personality on film, but his bungling tenancies are completely absent in this film. Also it was good to see Shirley Jones, who I only recall from the Partridge Family and also Ron Howard in one of his earliest roles.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

